Thursday 04 December 2008 | The Royal Family feed | All feeds

Advertisement

Queen's composer attacks 'dumbing down' of British society

The Queen's composer has launched a stinging attack on the "dumbing down" of British society, singling out the commercialisation of art and Damien Hirst for particular criticism.

 
Sir Peter Maxwell Davies - Queen's composer attacks 'dumbing down' of British society
Sir Peter said that in today's Britain art 'has become part of the entertainment industry, crossed with investment banking' Photo: CHARLIE HOPKINSON

Sir Peter Maxwell Davies, whose official title is the Queen's Master of Music, described Hirst's work - which recently raised £111 million at auction - as "manufactured artefacts without content."

In a speech to the conference of the British Academy of Composers and Songwriters, he also criticised politicians and educationalists and warned that the country was in an "age of commercial depravity and irresponsibility".

He expressed concern over the perception that classical music was elitist, which he described as inverted snobbery, and said politicians had dumbed down so much they were "almost below the horizon".

Sir Peter, 74, used Hirst's record breaking auction at Sotheby's last month, which included The Golden Calf, a bull with gold horns and hoofs in a tank of formaldehyde that sold for £10.3 million, as an example of what was wrong with art today.

"I think we can all learn from a recent auction of art as an instantly recognisable iconic commodity, where it has become part of the entertainment industry, crossed with investment banking," he said.

"The artist had wit to sell a golden calf and other bejewelled trinkets, but all creative artists, in whatever branch of the arts they work, must ponder the implications of so much money scrambling after manufactured artefacts without content, with just a brand tag supposed to guarantee market value.

"The pressures on us to conform to this image of 'success' in our various art worlds are enormous.

"It reminds me of the Liberace museum in Las Vegas, where the great man's tatty stage costumes are exhibited, each with a fabulous price tag, and we are supposed to be uplifted.

"There are, of course, interesting visual artists out there, but this auction pantomime reflects the reductio ad absurdum (Latin for "reduced to the absurd") of an art world where the principles of the market reign supreme."

Sir Peter, who lives in Orkney and is known to his friends as Max, is regarded as one of Britain's most important living composers and conductors.

He told his audience at the Royal Overseas League in London that Britain's composers led the world, but the pressures on them to conform to market forces were incredible. He traced the current malaise back to Margaret Thatcher.

"Over the last decades, since Thatcher, every commodity, including culture, not only has to be 'approachable,' but, above all, have a measurable market, or commercial value, and must be demonstrably accessible to the largest spread of public. My main concern is how this is changing the face of our musical culture," he said.

"Politics has dumbed itself down to almost below the horizon, with the public given no credit for intelligence or intellect, while, ironically, ever fewer people trouble to vote, such is the disillusion and disgust.

Sir Peter also took a swipe at educationalists and the "lowest common denominator" rule which meant that "nothing must be challenging, where blandness is all-pervasive, where students at all levels must feel good, confident, and at all costs never be allowed to imagine they could ever, if they don't work, be considered a failure".

Hirst, 43, dominated the art scene in the 1990s, largely due to his association with the collector Charles Saatchi, and last month took the unusual step of selling a complete show at Sotheby's, breaking the record for a one-artist auction in the process.

 
State Opening of Parliament
Advertisement
Advertisement

EDITOR'S CHOICE

French Foreign Legion? - it's an option

French Foreign Legion; The French Foreign Legion - the last option for those desperate to escape the UK

Lost your job, your home, your business? Is the wife about to take you to the cleaners? If only one could forget it all and start again.

most viewed

Sponsored Features

Specsavers

Try on thousands of frames online and win a style makeover worth £1000 with Specsavers.

My South African Feast

Chef Mark Gilchrist reveals his top South African recipes. Read them and then tell us your own.

Caribbean Paradise

Welcome to the Spice Island of Grenada - one of the Caribbean’s most beautiful and unspoilt destinations.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Jewel in the crown

The Imperial State Crown is carried from the Palace of Westminster following the State Opening of Parliament

The ceremonial State Opening of Parliament and the Queen's Speech.

Pants down politicians

The 'caganer' (literally 'defecator') is a feature of Catalan nativity scenes.

Britney Spears comeback

Britney Spears had a third 'comeback' performance on American TV.

Classified

Give a pet a home

Search the Telegraph Market Place for kittens, puppies and even pigs, as well as all your pet accessory needs.

50 Free Downloads

We've teamed up with eMusic to offer Telegraph readers the latest music downloads.

Sign language: week 27

Sign language

Another selection of strange signs sent in by readers on their travels.

Christmas decoration - The Christmas gifts that will keep on giving

Presents that keep giving

Give someone the gift of wealth this Christmas.

Alexander McCall Smith's Courduroy Mansions online novel: Read a chapter a day, a few at a time or all at once at Telegraph.co.uk

Alexander McCall Smith

Online novel: Read a chapter a day, a few at a time or all at once.

Win a £1,000 style makeover with Specsavers on Telegraph.co.uk

Win a style makeover

Don't miss your chance to indulge with a makeover worth £1,000.

Back to top

More Telegraph.co.uk

Archive Contact us Reader prints RSS feeds Subscribe and save Syndication Today's news

© Copyright of Telegraph Media Group Limited 2008 Terms & Conditions of reading Commercial information Privacy and Cookie Policy.